Hadith › Sahih al-Bukhari › Disputed Narration

Bukhari 1471

The leper, the bald man and the blind man — phrase 'it occurred to Allah' deemed inappropriate

Hadith Text

This entry references a hadith that is available in full on this site.

Read Bukhari 1471 in full

Bukhari reference: Bukhari 1471

Scholarly Critique

Scholar: al-Albani
Critique Type: Matn criticism (theological wording concern)
Scholar Grading: Weakened by al-Albani (specific phrase)

IslamQA #178907: al-Albani objects to specific phrasing, not the tradition as a whole.

Final Assessment and Source

Final Grade: Hasan at most (per al-Albani) / Sahih (per majority)
Source: IslamQA fatwa #178907

About al-Albani All disputed narrations in Sahih al-Bukhari What is Tatabbu'?